Fill vs Workday VNDLY

A focused alternative to Workday VNDLY.

The active procurement system for your consultant workforce. Agents guide each request to a signed agreement and follow up when a decision is waiting. A person makes every decision.

Compared on the work you still have to do

Criterion
Fill
Workday VNDLY
Product focus
Active consultant procurement, built around the hiring manager: one record per engagement from request to invoice.
Contingent work broadly: temporary workers, consultants, freelancers and statement of work (SOW) services.
Hiring-manager experience
Plain-language requests and guidance during the hire help the manager complete it.
Automated requisitions, shortlisting and interview management for hiring managers.
Agents in everyday use
Agents follow up when a decision is waiting, flag contract differences for review and adapt extension follow-up to what the manager wants.
A Contingent Sourcing Agent for talent rediscovery and applicant grading, plus machine learning to find candidates.
Results
Pilot customers rated the hiring process clearly higher after their pilot.
Analyst recognition: a Leader in Everest Group's VMS PEAK Matrix 2026.
Implementation scope
Scoped to consultant hiring: your suppliers, approval steps and the Workday HCM connection.
No implementation timeline published.
EU fit
EU data residency, BankID identity and no training on your data.
Workday says core data for EU-headquartered customers stays in Europe; we found no VNDLY-specific statement.
The reason to choose
A manager experience people use and less coordination for procurement, measured in pilots.
One vendor for every kind of contingent worker, next to Workday HCM; pricing is not published.
▣Guided requests
⊞Agents follow up
≡Contract differences flagged
☰A person makes every decision

Where Fill differs from Workday VNDLY.

  • 01Built around the hiring manager: plain-language requests and guidance during the hire.
  • 02Agents follow up when a decision is waiting, so requests keep moving.
  • 03Procurement sees each request early and spends its time on commercial judgement.
  • 04Agents prepare and follow up; a person makes every decision.

What customers see in a pilot.

Setup
Vendors imported
HRIS connected
Procurement live
Hiring managers onboarded

A scope you can see

Setup covers your suppliers, your approval steps and the Workday HCM connection, so consultant records sit next to your employee data.

Active consultants — All vendors
Janica EllisenKnowit
Sophie HabibSigma
Clara PedersenHiQ

Results from real pilots

Pilot customers rated the hiring process clearly higher after their pilot than before it.

EU residency & BankID
EU-hosted by default
BankID identity
GDPR & EU AI Act aligned
Nordic labour law ready

European by default

BankID identity, EU data residency and GDPR, for European procurement.

What a pilot with Fill shows.

A pilot starts from a real hiring need and is measured on what it asks of managers and of procurement.

Give hiring managers a process worth using.

Where Workday VNDLY is the better choice

If you run Workday HCM and want every type of contingent worker, from temps to freelancers, managed next to employees in Workday, VNDLY is the natural fit. Fill is a focused alternative when consultant hiring matters more than the breadth of a global workforce programme.

Talk to Fredrik

Choosing and changing VMS,
questions answered.

When is it worth changing VMS at all?

Not as often as vendors suggest. If your current system is embedded in working finance and procurement processes and your hiring managers use it unprompted, the disruption is not worth it. The honest trigger for a change is when the people raising requests route around the system, because a VMS that is bypassed produces no data, and without data there are no savings to find.

Can Fill work alongside Workday HCM?

Yes. Fill connects to Workday HCM and Workday Financials, so consultant records can sync with your HR data and approved purchase orders, hours and invoices can flow into finance, while sourcing, rates, contracts and extensions are handled in Fill.

How long does a VMS implementation take?

The technical setup is rarely the constraint. Time goes into agreeing approval hierarchies and spend policy across procurement, HR and finance, re-papering supplier agreements if they are changing, and running in parallel until in-flight engagements close. Ask any vendor for the elapsed time to first live request, not the configuration time.

What does a pilot with Fill look like?

It starts from a real hiring need. A manager writes the request, one decision is left open long enough to show the follow-up, and an approval or contract exception is handled with the decision kept by a person. Manager effort and procurement coordination are measured separately, and participation is counted against every eligible request.

What happens to your historical consultant data when you switch?

Insist on a full export before you sign anything, not at the point of leaving. Active engagements, supplier records, rate history and closed assignments should all be extractable in an open format. Rate history in particular is the asset that makes future benchmarking possible — losing it resets your negotiating position to zero.

What makes Fill different?

Fill is the active procurement system for your consultant workforce. Agents guide each request to a signed agreement, follow up when a decision is waiting and flag contract differences for review, and a person makes every decision. Procurement sees each request early and spends less time coordinating. It is software your own team runs, and it is European by default.

Take procurement off the spreadsheets.

See the product